Wishie Winners!

The results are in!

All the votes have been counted and the second annual Wishie Award winners have been announced.

So who won?

Click through to find out…

Best Design/ Most Visually Appealing


1. OnlinePregnancyCenter.com
2. AppBotic.com
3. Tapptics.com
4. HowToEarnMoney101.com
5. WorkYourArt.com

Winner: WorkYourArt.com


Best Marketing Strategy


1. TheQuadrantQuiz.com
2. BoxShotKing.com
3. SocialMediaOnlineClasses.com
4. MarketingGraphicsMonthly.com
5. MyTravelResearch.com
6. ResponseDynamite.com/vault

Winner: TheQuadrantQuiz.com


Most Unusual Membership Site


1. iDontStink.com
2. M0a.com/online-ground-school
3. PhotoRestorationSchool.com
4. PaperPunchFlowers.com
5. Hypothermics.com

Winner: iDontStink.com


Best Overall Membership Site


1. HerbMentor.com
2. RyanLee.com
3. EverydayBetter.com
4. SuccessEtc.com
5. AskCharlyLeetham.com

Winner: RyanLee.com


Most Valuable Insider Member


1. Blaine Moore
2. Rebekah Zobel-Jones
3. Charly Leetham
4. Jeff Pfau
5. David Brinton

Winner: Charly Leetham


Congratulations to all the finalists and winners! We were again blown away by all the incredible submissions and hope that the Wishies have provided you plenty of inspiration for your next membership site.


  1. Wray says:

    Congratulations to all the winners!

    We had a LOT of entries and a LOT of votes so thanks to everyone who participated 🙂

  2. Every winner here is well deserved. Congrats all.

  3. Jeff Pfau says:

    Nice job, everyone!
    There are some very creative and design-savvy webmasters out there!


  4. Congrats Everyone! Clearly there are 25 winners here – your sites are awesome and inspiring! Thanks so much for sharing and doing what you do!

  5. Congratulations to the winners and the finalists! I know I loved seeing everyone’s sites and getting a glimpse into the thought and design process behind them. Way to go!

  6. Wait, Best Design, it’s me, I won! I WON! I’m going nuts! Thank you SO much for all who voted, this is amazing, it means a lot to me and I’m so very grateful. WOW! Congrats to all who won and got nominated – only winners on this list and throughout the community, for sure. Great to explore all of those wonderful websites out there and looking forward to a new year with inspiring members. Thanks!!

    • Wray says:

      Congratulations @Debbie 🙂

      We’re happy to see that you are happy! We’re sure you’ll have a very successful year ahead of you.

    • Stu McLaren says:

      Way to go Debbie – it really is a beautiful design and you definitely deserve the win.

      Perhaps we should do a case study so everyone can see the “inside” as well 🙂

      BTW – keep your eyes open for an email from our team… you’ve also got a nice little “prize pack” coming your way 😉

  7. Congratulations to all the winners. It was great to visit all the sites and see the many different ways we all use WLM.

  8. Congratulations to the winners and nominees – all of them very deserving indeed!

  9. Stu McLaren says:

    It was so great to see all the submissions this year but I gotta admit, I love seeing Insiders win the votes of the general public 🙂

    Congrats to all the winners!

  10. YAY! Ryan Lee won! Ryan Lee rocks WOOT WOOT! Congrads to all of the winners and even the contestants great sites!

    Still waiting for Wray to do his Comic Book membership site called Wray Reading Comic Books While Your Butt Naked in your Room membership dot com LOL

    Or Stus “Barely excited membership” (insert sarcasm here)

    • Wray says:

      Good to hear from you @Darren!

      I’ll have to see if that domain you mentioned it taken, it seems like someone would have grabbed that one up already 😉

  11. Noah Fleming says:

    I just think IDontStink is one of the most unique sites I’ve ever seen. Great stuff.

    • Wray says:

      @Noah – It is a really cool site. I remember when I first saw it nominated I thought to myself “That is definitely a unique site”

  12. Way to go Ryan!!!
    One of my fav clients 😉
    Congrats to Karen – my awesome designer who did Ryan’s homepage – way to go!!!

    Congrats to everyone who won – a much tougher vote than last year…

  13. Tourism Tim says:

    2 Thumbs Up for all the winners!

    What was the selection criteria for the Best Marketing Strategy?

    Was the vote just WLI member driven or did the leadership team have specifics they were looking for in the “Best Marketing Strategy”.

    Highest opt-in rate? Sales conversion rate? Offer? Copy writing? Value? Retention?

    Trying to better understand “best practices” as you all see it.

    Thanks for your help.

    • Wray says:

      @Tourism Tim – When it came to selecting finalists, we considered a number of factors in regards to marketing.

      We looked at the niche of the site and how the site itself addressed the wants and needs of it’s targeted market.

      We also considered things like sales pages, ease of purchase, etc. along with many of the points you mentioned.

      Then, it was up to all those who voted to choose who they thought should win 🙂

  14. WY says:

    Just want to thank Wishlist for for choosing me as a finalist in the “Best Marketing Strategy” category.

    I have set up a number of membership sites and I have to say WIshlist is, hands down, my favorite membership software.

    Thanks everyone who voted for me, all the choices were so good that I appreciate your vote.

    Anyway, thanks WL for making my life easier.


    • Wray says:

      @WY – Your site was very deserving of being nominated and we’re happy to hear you’re enjoying WishList Member 🙂

      Any time we can make things easier for someone, that’s always awesome to hear!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Posts